Wednesday, October 05, 2005

Freedom of Silence

An article published on military.com states that the Army is starting to clampdown on blogging servicepersons in the great name of OPSEC (Operations Security). Whereas the argument at face value makes sense--the opposing side does read any accessible information about the U.S., including anything that hints at the morale of the troops, being ex-military I have enough sense to know that this has less to do with OPSEC and more to do with domestic PSY/OPS. One of the understatements of the decade is that the war in Iraq is not exactly popular now, and the "enemy" that the Army is truly concerned with is the American media. It would be even more difficult for the Bush administration to hold on to the sliver of support it does have if some ambitious reporter just happen to take a soldier's thoughts and share them with the general population. Whereas I genuinely understand that certain soldiers cannot discuss details of their day at work, the handful of blogs I have seen appear to be just an outlet for stress. What the military fails to realize is that if they block this stress outlet, they really will have a problem on their hands in the future. People underestimate the power of emotion. It is emotion that fuels the drive for these soldiers to push forward with their mission and if not checked, these same emotions will churn until an outlet becomes a necessity. If unchecked, those emotions could manifest into violence, whether internalized (suicide) or expressed (this runs the gamut). Whereas I realize there are Beetle Baileys in every group I sincerely doubt there are that many soldiers stupid enough to put sensitive information on the web. If any are doing that, then I am willing to contend that for many of them it was probably on purpose. If this is not the case, then the Army needs to focus more on sensitive information security training instead of taking away the only quiet space these soldiers probably have left.

2 comments:

Human said...

The "clampdown" is becuse of the response of people like me who after seeing many Mil. bloggers that are anti-war either shut down or reprimanded began a campaign to see that what was good for ones who are pro Peace should be good for ones who glorify war.

Many of the pro Peace mil bloggers have been threatened and harrassed for none other reason than speaking the truth.

The OPSEC was just an excuse to shut them up.

S said...

I agree. When I was in, they would just isolate the ones that questioned our orders (such as myself) and "phased us out" of the system, but now there are so many dissenters that this tactic is not working. I have dozens of letters from my aunt when she was stationed there expressing her rage about the entire fiasco. They cannot tell these soldiers what they are dying for, and that was a weakness from day one. There is no "cause." You think they would have learned this after committing the same error during Vietnam.